The Psychology of Sin Sells: Research Shows Immoral Symbols Drive Purchase Intent

Source:

Ilicic, J., Brennan, S.M. & Kulczynski, A. Sinfully decadent: priming effects of immoral advertising symbols on indulgence. Marketing Letters 32, 61–73 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-020-09544-6

---

In the latest episode of Marketing Science Lab, we explore fascinating new research that challenges conventional wisdom about using moral and immoral symbols in advertising. The study, published in Marketing Letters, reveals that incorporating "immoral" symbols like devils and serpents - along with rebellious messaging - can significantly increase consumer indulgence and purchase intent.

The Power of Immoral Symbols in Modern Marketing

The use of moral and religious symbols in advertising has seen explosive growth, increasing nearly 500% in magazine advertisements between 1969 and 2013. But what's truly compelling is how these symbols affect consumer behavior. The research demonstrates that when brands incorporate immoral symbols (devils, serpents, hell imagery) rather than moral ones (angels, saints, heaven), consumers are significantly more likely to indulge in purchase decisions.

Key Research Findings:

• Timing Matters: Presenting immoral symbols before or during product presentation increased indulgence by up to 20%, while showing them after had no effect

• Rebellion Sells: Messages like "Break the Rules" amplified indulgent choices regardless of imagery

• Real-World Impact: The effect translated to actual purchase behavior, not just stated intentions

The Psychology Behind the Effect

What makes immoral symbols so effective? The research points to "rebelliousness activation" - these symbols tap into our innate desire to break free from constraints and indulge in pleasure. This psychological mechanism works independently of religious beliefs or conventional image-message congruence.

Practical Applications for Marketers

Not all brands should rush to incorporate devils into their advertising. The effect works best for:

• Luxury Products and Services

  • High-end automobiles

  • Premium spirits

  • Exclusive experiences

• Adventure and Entertainment

  • Travel packages

  • Extreme sports

  • Entertainment venues

• Indulgent Consumer Goods

  • Premium chocolates

  • High-end personal care

  • Luxury fashion

Implementation Strategies

To effectively leverage this research:

• Timing is Critical

  • Place immoral symbols at the beginning of advertisements

  • Incorporate them within product presentation

  • Avoid post-product symbol placement

• Message Alignment

  • Use rebellious messaging to amplify effect

  • Don't worry about strict image-message congruence

  • Keep context appropriate for your brand

• Testing and Refinement

  • Conduct A/B testing with different symbol variations

  • Monitor audience response

  • Adjust based on data-driven insights

Best Practices and Considerations

While the research shows promising results, implementation requires careful consideration:

• Brand Alignment: Ensure the approach aligns with your brand values

• Cultural Sensitivity: Consider cultural interpretations of symbols

• Target Audience: Understand your demographic's receptiveness

• Product Category: Evaluate appropriateness for your industry

The research emphasizes that subtle implementation often works best. Rather than obvious devil imagery, consider:

• Dark color schemes

• Subtle rebellious messaging

• Implied rule-breaking

• Sophisticated "forbidden fruit" references

Looking Ahead

This research opens new possibilities for creative marketing strategies, but success lies in thoughtful implementation. The key is finding the sweet spot between rebellion and responsibility, between indulgence and restraint.

Practical Takeaways:

1. Consider incorporating subtle "immoral" symbols in advertising for indulgent products

2. Time symbol placement carefully - before or during product presentation

3. Use rebellious messaging to amplify effect

4. Test different approaches with your specific audience

5. Monitor results and adjust strategy accordingly

The research provides compelling evidence that strategic use of immoral symbols and rebellious messaging can significantly impact consumer behavior. However, success requires careful consideration of brand alignment, cultural context, and target audience receptiveness.

For marketers looking to differentiate their brands and tap into consumers' natural inclination toward indulgence, this research provides valuable insights into the psychology of purchase decisions and the power of symbolic marketing.

Dive into the intriguing world of marketing psychology with this presentation exploring how "sinful" imagery can influence consumer behavior. Discover the research and insights behind why immoral symbols might just be the key to unlocking purchase intent.